The New York Yankees are actively exploring the free-agent market to strengthen their bullpen following the departure of key players and the loss of Juan Soto to the New York Mets. Soto’s move to Queens left a void in the Yankees’ roster, prompting the organization to focus on other critical areas, including bolstering their relief pitching. With several notable relievers already signed or unavailable, the Yankees must act decisively to fill these gaps.
The Yankees’ Bullpen Dilemma
The Yankees face the challenge of replacing departing relievers like Tim Hill, Tim Mayza, and former closer Clay Holmes, who also signed with the Mets in free agency. Losing key bullpen pieces has intensified the need for reinforcements, especially after falling short in the World Series. The free-agent market offers opportunities, but competition has already claimed several viable options. Former Blue Jays closer Jordan Romano signed with the Phillies, while Genesis Cabrera joined the Mets, and Connor Gillispie went to the Braves. Despite these losses, the Yankees still have notable arms available to consider.
Paul Sewald: A Versatile Option
One intriguing candidate is right-hander Paul Sewald, who previously served as a closer for the Arizona Diamondbacks. At 34 years old, Sewald isn’t a dominant closer but brings flexibility and reliability to the bullpen. In 2024, he pitched 39 2/3 innings, saving 16 games while blowing only four. His 4.31 ERA, 43 strikeouts, and 10 walks reflect a solid performance, though not elite. Sewald’s versatility could make him an excellent setup option ahead of Luke Weaver, the Yankees’ potential closer, or as a situational closer himself.
Sewald relies on a mix of fastballs, sweepers, and changeups. While he doesn’t overpower hitters with velocity, his command and ability to generate weak contact make him effective. His role in the bullpen could vary based on game situations, providing manager Aaron Boone with a reliable arm for high-leverage moments.
Kirby Yates: A Proven Veteran
Another option is veteran right-hander Kirby Yates, who had a stellar 2024 season with the Texas Rangers. Yates ranked seventh among MLB closers, saving 33 games with a remarkable 1.17 ERA across 61 2/3 innings. The 37-year-old also posted a 7-2 record, demonstrating his reliability in tight situations. A two-time All-Star (2019, 2024), Yates rebounded from injury setbacks earlier in his career to reestablish himself as a dominant late-inning reliever.
Yates’ arsenal includes a four-seam fastball, split-finger, and slider, with his fastball averaging 94 mph and featuring significant vertical and horizontal movement. He excels at inducing groundouts (45.5% in 2024) and limiting hard contact, with just 4.1% barrel rate against him. His ability to execute pitches effectively in crucial moments makes him an invaluable asset.
Strategic Fit for the Yankees
Both Sewald and Yates would address the Yankees’ bullpen needs, offering versatility, experience, and reliability. Sewald’s adaptability makes him a suitable setup man or secondary closer, while Yates’ veteran presence and playoff experience could stabilize the bullpen in high-pressure situations. Adding either or both relievers would provide the Yankees with depth and flexibility as they aim to return to the World Series.
With the American League still wide open, prioritizing a strong bullpen is essential for the Yankees. Pursuing Sewald and Yates would be strategic moves to enhance their chances of postseason success while addressing a key area of need.
