As Skol Nation transitions from the frenzy of free agency to focusing on the NFL draft, attention is centered on Kwesi Adofo-Mensah. This will mark his third draft as the Vikings’ general manager, with results presenting a mixed picture. While his first-round pick, Lewis Cine, hasn’t made a significant impact, his subsequent top selection, Jordan Addison, has been a valuable addition, along with undrafted free agent signing Ivan Pace. Other picks such as Akayleb Evans, Ty Chandler, Ed Ingram, and Mekhi Blackmon have shown potential but need to demonstrate greater consistency.
On April 25, Adofo-Mensah is set to make selections at the 11th and 23rd overall positions after obtaining an additional first-round draft pick through a trade. There is strong anticipation that he will orchestrate a trade to move up into the top five picks and secure a successor for Kirk Cousins in the draft, considering Cousins’ departure after six years of dependable quarterback performance for the organization.
USC standout Caleb Williams is strongly predicted to be Chicago’s first overall pick, while Jayden Daniels from LSU is expected to go second to Washington. This scenario leaves North Carolina’s Drake Maye and Michigan’s J.J. McCarthy as potential options unless unexpected developments occur.
The New England Patriots might select Maye third overall to address their quarterback vacancy, which has been open since Tom Brady’s departure in 2020. McCarthy’s draft stock has significantly risen recently, increasing the likelihood that he could be chosen before the Giants’ sixth pick. This situation may necessitate Adofo-Mensah to trade with the Cardinals or Chargers, who hold the fourth and fifth picks, respectively.
Michigan’s JJ McCarthy drew attention during the team’s Pro Day, particularly for his throwing session observed by QB coach Josh McCown. ESPN’s draft analyst Matt Miller noted McCarthy’s impressive performance, highlighting his accuracy, zip, touch, and ability to connect on deep routes. McCarthy aimed to showcase his touch placement, an aspect of his game that has previously been a concern, as he tended to rely more on throwing lasers than touch passes. This versatility in his throwing style is crucial for NFL quarterbacks, demonstrating McCarthy’s development and readiness for the professional level.
At the combine, McCarthy addressed concerns about his physical frame by weighing in at 219 lbs, dispelling doubts about his ability to withstand the physical demands of the NFL.
It’s worth noting that impressive performances in practice settings like Pro Days don’t always translate to success in actual games. A notable example is Zach Wilson, who showcased similar skills during his BYU Pro Day but has struggled in the NFL due to issues with reading defenses and accuracy. In contrast, McCarthy excels at reading defenses and has shown maturity both on and off the field.
While McCarthy may not have received as much recognition for leading Michigan to a national championship, it’s important to acknowledge his contributions. Despite playing in a team with a strong rushing attack, he demonstrated his capabilities in crucial moments, earning recognition as one of the top third-down quarterbacks in college football.
J.J. McCarthy possesses several qualities that make him an intriguing prospect for the NFL. His athleticism and arm talent suggest he has the potential to succeed as a quarterback at the professional level. Additionally, his natural leadership abilities and football intelligence point towards a high ceiling for his career.
However, one area of uncertainty lies in McCarthy’s experience of carrying a team, as he hasn’t had to do so extensively in college. This raises questions about his ability to lead a team effectively if required. Furthermore, his statistical production may not match up with some of the other top quarterbacks in the upcoming draft.
The Minnesota Vikings are taking a closer look at McCarthy by scheduling a private workout with the 21-year-old prospect. With the expertise of two former NFL quarterbacks on their coaching staff, the Vikings have a solid opportunity to evaluate McCarthy and determine if he fits their vision for the future.
